Thread Report
AllSaints vs Carhartt: Fabric Quality.
We compared 1,245 AllSaints products against 45 Carhartt products. Carhartt comes out significantly ahead at 100% average natural fibre vs AllSaints's 54.8%.
Head-to-Head
Average Natural Fibre %
Polyester-Heavy Products %
Nearly All-Natural Products %
By Category
| Category | AllSaints (count) | Carhartt (count) | Diff |
|---|---|---|---|
| T-Shirt | 93.1% (169) | 100% (38) | -6.9 |
Monthly Thread Reports
Get reports like this in your inbox.
We analyze thousands of products every month. Be the first to see new Thread Reports — fabric data nobody else publishes.
No spam. Unsubscribe in one click.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is AllSaints or Carhartt better quality?
In terms of fabric composition, Carhartt averages 100% natural fibre compared to AllSaints's 54.8%. Higher natural fibre content generally means better quality, breathability, and fewer microplastics.
AllSaints vs Carhartt: which uses more polyester?
AllSaints uses more polyester — 24.1% of their products are polyester-heavy, vs 0% at Carhartt.
Should I shop at AllSaints or Carhartt?
If fabric quality matters to you, Carhartt has the edge with 100% average natural fibre. But quality varies by product — use the Fibr extension to check individual items while you shop at either retailer.
Related reports.
Stop buying plastic by accident.
Fibr shows you what every garment is actually made of before you buy it. Green means natural fibre. Red means plastic.
Add to Chrome — It's freeFree forever. No account, no data collected, nothing to lose.